Review #995 - Elijah Craig Barrel Proof Batch Y1223 (Heaven Hill 'You Do Bourbon' Experience)

In these final 10 reviews leading up to review #1000, we've decided to take a look at whiskies from distilleries which, at one point or another in our exploration of whisky, have become more meaningful to us than most others. These 10 distilleries had impacts on journey for a variety of reasons, reasons which we'll dig into in each review.

The reasons we picked Heaven Hill to be one of our 10 distilleries are quite simple. First, we love their bourbons - they're one of our favorite American producers, and we always have several of their products on our shelf. Second, this was one of the first distilleries that we visited, and we've been back a few times - that's where we picked up this bottle that we're reviewing today. And third, and maybe most importantly, this is our most-reviewed distillery over our first 1,000 reviews. Today's Elijah Craig makes it 41 Heaven Hill reviews, by our count; here's a breakdown of the top 10 distilleries in our archive of reviews:

1. Heaven Hill - 41 reviews

2. Buffalo Trace - 40 reviews

3. New Riff - 38 reviews

4. Jim Beam - 31 reviews

5. Bruichladdich - 27 reviews

T-6. Laphroaig - 25 reviews

T-6. Kilchoman - 25 reviews

T-8. Four Roses - 23 reviews

T-8. Springbank - 23 reviews

10. Wild Turkey - 17 reviews

While we actually have more reviews in the Scotch realm as opposed to American whiskies, those Scotch reviews are spread over a wider array of distilleries, whereas the bourbon and rye reviews are much more concentrated around a few large heritage producers. That's why the top 4 distilleries, and 6 of the top 10 in total, hail from the US.

One of the reasons we have so many Heaven Hill reviews is the prevalence of Elijah Craig - it's one of our go-to bourbons, and due to the plethora of seasonal Barrel Proof releases and the plentiful private barrels/store picks out there, we've had ample opportunity to try different versions. While the more recent Barrel Proof versions have lacked some of the special character that the old 12+ year versions had, we still think it's a solid bourbon line, and we always have a couple in our bottle rotation.

This barrel proof version we're looking at today is a little different - it was only available as a part of the Heaven Hill 'You Do Bourbon' experience, a tour and tasting session at their visitor center just south of Bardstown, Kentucky. In the tasting experience, you go through a series of barrel proof whiskies, and the specific whiskies rotate based on availability. In our tour in early 2024, we had a lineup of Elijah Craig Barrel Proof Bourbon, Larceny Barrel Proof, Bernheim Barrel Proof, and Heaven Hill Select Stock, which was a Kentucky Malt Whiskey at the time (9 years old, mashbill of 51% malted barley, 49% corn). When it came time to choose a whisky to take home, we selected this Elijah Craig and the Select Stock malt whisky.

The Elijah Craig bourbons bottled as a part of this distillery experience have a different code than the usual A-B-C Barrel Proof batch theme: the letter at the start of the batch is 'Y' (presumably for 'You' Do Bourbon), and for our batch specifically, the numerical code following the letter is 1223. We're guessing that this is a reference to December 2023, which is presumably when they started offering this specific batch of EC Barrel Proof in the tasting experience.

This is a 10 year old Elijah Craig, and our bottling strength is 59.6% ABV (119.2 proof), and as usual with these bourbons, the mashbill is 78% corn, 10% rye, and 12% malted barley. After tasting this at the distillery, we waited a couple of years before opening this bottle - let's get back into it.

Elijah Craig Barrel Proof Batch Y1223 (Heaven Hill 'You Do Bourbon' Experience)

USA - Bourbon

Price: USD 80 (2024)

Age Statement: 10 Years

Strength: 59.6% ABV

Details: Not chill filtered, batch Y1223, bottled 2024

Tasting Methodology: Reviewed 3 times over 2 months; bottles at 100%, 80%, and 70% fill levels at times of review. Tasted in a nosing glass each time, rested 15+ minutes

Nose: Spicy and herbal, with a decent amount of dark oak. Cardamom, brown sugar, caramel, and wood char combine with leathery tannins, menthol, toasted rye bread, and some dry almond or walnut. There's a subtle dessert side - chocolate-caramel pecan turtles, and then a hint of fudge, but we also get drying notes of licorice, raw rye grain, and a touch of tobacco.

Palate: The mouthfeel is medium-thick; we get some caramel and brown sugar, along with lots of herbal rye notes: sage, smoked rosemary, menthol, some licorice. Grassy notes and an earthy quality build, and we also find white pepper and fermented tobacco. It definitely leans spicy overall.

Finish: Earthy and spicy notes continue - drying oak tannins, spearmint, lots of rye character. The oak grows stronger over time, and we also get some brown sugar and caramel again. Vanilla and a bready note linger in the aftertaste; it's a medium-long, softly warming finish.

Final Note: Are we sure this is actually a bourbon? This is the most rye-forward Elijah Craig bourbon we've ever tasted, by a wide margin - tons of herb and spice notes dominated the whole experience, though there was some sweetness from those brown sugar and caramel notes, too. The oaky side started off as a bit reserved, but it grows more tannic into the finish. Overall, it's quite a spicy bourbon, but we like it for that - it's a bit unusual.

As for value, we think this is above average based on the $80 price tag we paid to get this during the tasting experience. That doesn't factor in the cost of the tour to get this chance in the first place, but we still think the whole thing was worth it - we ended up with a couple of interesting whiskies, and it was fun to learn more about the Heaven Hill history and mashbills along the way.

Our Rating: 7.2 / 10

In the current whisky landscape of increasing prices and variable quality, we've added a value rating to our reviews that relates to the score and the available pricing of each whisky. This roughly equates to a 0-10 scale; no reviews so far have exceeded a score of 10, although it is technically possible for the formula to produce a value rating higher than 10 with a high enough score and low enough price.

Value Rating: 6.65

About Us: We're a husband and wife review team living in the Midwest United States. Generally, our reviews and tasting notes will be a compilation of both of our experiences with a whisky over several tasting sessions.

Next
Next

Review #994 - Springbank 12 Year Cask Strength Batch 27