Review #996 - SMWS 149.13 'West-Coast Succulence' - Ardnamurchan 8 Year

In these final 10 reviews leading up to review #1000, we've decided to take a look at whiskies from distilleries which, at one point or another in our exploration of whisky, have become more meaningful to us than most others. These 10 distilleries had impacts on journey for a variety of reasons, reasons which we'll dig into in each review.

In our last review, which covered the Batch Y1223 Barrel Proof version of Elijah Craig bourbon, we described how Heaven Hill is our most-reviewed distillery. That's completely true, but there's actually an individual brand that we've reviewed far more than any specific distillery: the Scotch Malt Whisky Society. While we've now reviewed 41 whiskies from Elijah Craig, this review today brings us to 92 SMWS reviews, far more than any other brand. A big reason for that is the core concept of independent bottlers: you can try a wide variety of different distilleries and styles, all under the same brand. And, while a lot of independent bottlers have only recently become available to buy or ship here in Indianapolis, SMWS has been available here for quite some time.

The main reason we picked this whisky to feature in our run up to review #1000, though, was the distillery: Ardnamurchan. Over the past 3 to 4 years, this has become one of our favorite distilleries, and it really taught us how good young whisky can be, and how much the new wave of Scottish distilleries has to offer. Ardnamurchan started production in July 2014, so their oldest possible stocks are just passing the 12 year mark at the time of writing, but this distillery is already showing the rest of the new wave what quality young whisky can be. They use high quality distillate, high quality casks, and plenty of ingenuity to create a diverse range of tasty whiskies - all things we love to see.

This is the 13th Ardnamurchan we've covered in our reviews, and the average score from these is well above our overall average scoring for whiskies as a whole. The average value we've assigned for this distillery is also far above what we're seeing from most other producers - we think that Ardnamurchan is producing great distillate, but they're also charging very fair prices for their whiskies, which makes us like them even more.

It seems like we've tried Ardnamurchan spirit in just about every cask type imaginable now - sherry, Madeira, Sauternes, mezcal, Champagne, and more. For this review, though, we're looking at a stripped-back version of their whisky: full maturation in a first fill bourbon cask, and this whisky was made using unpeated distillate. This single cask was aged a total of 8 years, which makes it one of the older Ardnamurchan whiskies released, although at this point they have already bottled 10 year and 11 year stock.

SMWS placed this whisky in their 'Oily & Coastal' flavor profile, which has been one of our favorite profiles to buy from them - we love those coastal whiskies with their briny, mineral flavor influences. We think Ardnamurchan fits very well in that category as well with its salt and pepper spirit notes, and this specific release looks like it should put all of that character on display.

SMWS doesn't chill filter their whiskies, and they don't add color, so we have a natural presentation here; that's emphasized by the powerful cask strength of 62.7% ABV.

SMWS 149.13 'West-Coast Succulence' - Ardnamurchan 8 Year

Scotland/Highland - Single Malt

Price: USD 125 (2025)

Age Statement: 8 Years

Strength: 62.7% ABV

Cask Makeup: First fill ex-bourbon barrel

Details: Not chill filtered, no color added; distilled March 24, 2016; 216 bottles

Tasting Methodology: Reviewed 3 times over 2 months; bottles at 100%, 90%, and 70% fill levels at times of review. Tasted in a nosing glass each time, rested 15+ minutes

Nose: Malty and salty, it smells oily and quite coastal. It's a bit starchy and grain-forward as well with hay and dry bread crusts; fruits arrive in the form of honey-coated pears, apples, and a bit of orange. Drying oak, vanilla, floral perfume, and barley sugar build, and this smells very punchy and strong.

Palate: Malt and honey, briny, and there are sour lemons and sweet lemon candies leading the way. We get a strong pineapple influence, as well as a softer tropical fruit - borderline passionfruit? Vanilla, oranges, apples, cake batter, unripe pear, and sharp peach come next, along with a peppery bite. The mouthfeel is thick - amazing heft and texture, actually, and this does bring some spirity heat too.

Finish: Oily, salty, dry driftwood on the beach, and fizzy malt - similar to the nose and palate, with the addition of more oak. Bleached wood, a bit of malted grain, and some tinned fruits of peach and pear build, and we also find sharp lemon, nectarine, and fizzy pineapple. It's quite hot and spirity, and there's a bit of a youthful side to it; this finish is medium-long due to that heat.

Final Note: The official SMWS tasting notes for this whisky suggested strong influence of minerals and citrus - that's pretty much dead on, as far as we're concerned. Lots of salty, briny, and mineral character, and there's a strong light fruit note as well, much of which is quite tart and sharp. There's a strong malty side as well, as you would expect from an ex-bourbon malt at 8 years old; because of that youth, this does come across as very spirity, too, and a bit hot overall. Not too much complexity has had time to develop, it's a relatively straightforward single malt.

Overall, we find this to be a decent whisky, but it isn't among our favorite Ardnamurchans so far. One thing we do love is the texture - this has a crazy thick mouthfeel, tons of oily spirit and viscosity.

Value-wise, this suffers a little bit from SMWS syndrome - pretty expensive for the age statement, and also expensive for the flavor in the bottle. It's a solid whisky, but at a cost of $125, value is well below average.

Our Rating: 6.8 / 10

In the current whisky landscape of increasing prices and variable quality, we've added a value rating to our reviews that relates to the score and the available pricing of each whisky. This roughly equates to a 0-10 scale; no reviews so far have exceeded a score of 10, although it is technically possible for the formula to produce a value rating higher than 10 with a high enough score and low enough price.

Value Rating: 5.47

About Us: We're a husband and wife review team living in the Midwest United States. Generally, our reviews and tasting notes will be a compilation of both of our experiences with a whisky over several tasting sessions.

Previous
Previous

Review #997 - Bruichladdich Greener Still

Next
Next

Review #995 - Elijah Craig Barrel Proof Batch Y1223 (Heaven Hill 'You Do Bourbon' Experience)